Ali Ataie – Flaw in Medieval Judaism Logic

One of the things

that the Jews in Medina, there's hadith that

indicates sound hadith that they would come into

the majlis of the prophet

and they would sneeze on purpose because they

wanted a prophet to say, you're hamakumullah. And

the prophet, salallahu alayhi wasalam, will say, Allahu

Yadikum. May Allah guide you. So some of

them believed he was a prophet, but they

said, but you're not from Bani Israel, so

you cannot abrogate the Torah. And so the

Quran wants to make an argument here. They

call Abraham Avraham Avinu. This is how Jews

refer to Abraham.

Our father Abraham.

You know, if you if you study systematic

theology

of medieval Judaism, almost all of them say

there can be no non Jewish prophets. Yet,

one of the greatest prophets in their book,

Ibrahim Alaihi Salam, not a Jew, not Jewish.

So this is this is just a lie.

And the Quran is pointing this out that

the prophet Sallallahu Alaihi Salam, he is like

Ibrahim in that sense.