Ahmad Kutty – Is Qurbani or Udhiyah wajib or recommended Do we have to do it every year

The question whether Ola here, or Kobani, or sacrifice is Wajid or

recommended is a very important question. Because there are a lot

of misunderstandings. Some people just insist that it is wajib so

that we can never skip it as long as we can afford it. And they go

as far as saying that every individual in a household should

also offer sacrifice.

Now, this is not the authentic view of preferred view of majority

of scholars. And that was not the practice of the Sahaba of

Rasulullah sallallahu wasallam who should know better about the

Sunnah of the Prophet sallallahu?

The majority view is that although here is a great sunnah, sunnah

marcada it's strongly recommended sunnah of the Prophet. It is not

obligatory. The Prophet sallallahu sallam said mon arada, when you

law he, whoever wishes to sacrifice. So it's clear from that

statement of the Prophet salallahu Alaihe Salam that if you wish to

sacrifice you can afford it you should do so it is a

recommendation. And this is how, you know our curse of the

comonomer hottub the most pious caliphs, you know, practices they

were not sacrificing every year to keep it one or two years. And why

the question was asked Imam Shafi said they did so in order to let

people know that it is not obligately it is only strongly

recommended. They don't want to make people confuse, you know, the

obligatory ritual with a sunnah ritual recommended practice. Now,

of course, one day did that Sahaba knew, you know, in the one of the

principles of jurisprudence sees if a Sahabi especially does

something and it is known to other companions of the Prophet. And

they if they were to know that it is wrong, they would characterize

the and because and there is no mention they were character. So it

is an EEG Masuku T is silent EMI or taciti Dima, so it's understood

by the companions of the Prophet sallallahu wasallam, that it is

not obligatory, it is strongly recommended. So you don't need to

do it. If there are if this money is needed for charitable you know,

other purposes, you can allocate to that cause nothing wrong with

that. I hope this is clear. Having said that, the Hanafi school is

remarkable Hanifa Of course, among the Hanafi scholar, and when we as

disciples, Abu Yusuf before with him on that, because Allah

subhanaw taala cited for suddenly Rob Biko and heart you know, so he

thought that he interpreted this idea of the Quran as an order. And

of course, according to jurisprudence, the order of Allah

subhanaw taala should be taken as an obligation of course, unless

there is a Kareena of course, to interpret otherwise, we have

ocarina actually. So this argument is the what is the what's the

Karina? Karina is what you're talking about the proof from our

workers to the economy.

So inshallah that is the authentic view. So it's strongly recommended

practice. Okay,