Abdur Rahman ibn Yusuf Mangera – Q&A The 15th Sha’ban, ibn Taymiya and Weak Hadith

Why do some people take the 15th of Shaban was a special day there

is no sahih Hadith on this. Isn't this based on a weak Hadith?

Yes it is. There is there are weak Hadith about it but the but the

Allama have pretty much all agreed including immuno Tamia in this

case as well, that the this has been the practice of many of the

set of solid

in celebrating doing special worship on the 15th of Shaban

despite the fact that it's on weak Hadith. And implicit in this

question is the fact that it is this idea that you can't use weak

Hadith this is totally false. This is totally a misunderstanding and

a massive error. Because if you look at some of the greatest of

their alumni, including your own Bihari, he has filled his book

with weak Hadith not sahih al Bukhari because that was written

specifically for sahih Hadith, but in is a double move forward. And

in a number of other books. He's got numerous dive Hadith in their

weak Hadith and so weak Hadith are not to throw away it's not like

they are rejected. The extremely weak ones yes, that they have to

be taken, you know, in that particular way or the fabricated

ones don't misunderstand weak Hadith for fabricate generations.

And according to Imam Muhammad and many of the other scholars, they

make it very clear when it comes to just following issues, not

rulings and injunctions and Aqeedah we Hadith work as long as

they're not extremely weak, so many of the relevant they've

they've taken the weak Hadith about 15 to Shabaab, and totally

make sure you keep away from this idea that weak Hadith are not to

be taken at all because you'd be going against what the majority of

great Allah mA or mA have ever been a mountain many, many weak

Hadith Imam Muhammad don't know humble Muslim achmad full of weak

Hadith, full of weak Hadith. In all of this, he has to accept

Bukhari and Muslim except Bukhari and Muslim. All the rest of them.

Have we had even though, right, and none of the other ma except

some, some strange ones from recent past who came and said,

Okay, let's get rid of all of the weak Hadith as though they have no

validity whatsoever. So don't get into that debate.