Abdur Rahman ibn Yusuf Mangera – Q&A Is There Anything Wrong Saying Ya Rasullulah

What is the ruling on saying Ya rasool Allah was told that this is

wrong and many other sects do it and we should refrain yet it is

hurting many nasheeds by default to say Jaros will Allah there's

nothing wrong with it. It's the Aqeedah that goes with it that is

corruptive. So, generally in the in the Indian subcontinent because

of a certain group who had a certain Aqeedah certain belief

when they said, Yeah rasool Allah, they believe that the Prophet

sallallahu sallam was like Allah available and looking at all

times. And that's when you say the Arasu lies like you're saying,

Yeah, Allah, that becomes corruptive. But if that's not the

case and out of love, you say, Yeah, Allah, just like, there's

many women, they say, oh, Ma, right there, mom is nobody there.

It's just Oh Ma. It's this kind of an expression. So there are many

levels that if you just say it out of Shulk out of extreme love for

him, just like that, and you know, he's not here. Right? He could be

other Allah could put him anywhere he wants, but you can't say he's

here right now. Just because you want him to be. He's not at your

bidding. Right? So if you just say just like that, just out of love

or expression, that's why Mala should return. He's got that in

poems as well. Right? My only use of Ludhiana in Abdullah Ahmed

serratus team has got a very good discussion whether if you do it

just out of poetry, write it just like you do in poetry, like you

say, a badass Abba, which means Oh breeze of the morning. I mean, you

know, you can't hear you, but you just say it's an expression. So

there is no Schilke in the exact words, but they imply shirk.

Right. So in certain contexts, so that's the way it is. But the

reason why the Hindustani orlimar, the Indian subcontinent, rather,

my generally avoided or generally discouraged generally is because

of the corrupt Aqeedah of certain groups, and thus, they just want

to close the door, but by default, there's nothing wrong with it.