Abdur Rahman ibn Yusuf Mangera – Q&A Can I Have a Dual Intention for the Six Fasts of Shawal and Qada

			So the question is actually about
if somebody, especially women,
		

			they have 10 days of fasting to
make up. So what they do is they
		

			first off to eat in shovel. And
they have a dual intention of this
		

			being for sure wall. So I get the
baraka of that and the blessing of
		

			that, and it's also my color. So
now generally this works in any
		

			other time, except this month,
according to many scholars.
		

			The reason here is different. So
for example, in any other time,
		

			if, for example, you come into the
masjid and the Imam has just
		

			started Salaat it's sooner to do
thorough cuts of of Dieter masjid,
		

			greeting the masjid prayer. But if
the Imam has already started for
		

			it, and you join the and you're
also intention was that I should
		

			have done Toorak ads, you will get
the reward of the indifference.
		

			Or, for example, you saw that
there's only a few minutes left, I
		

			need to do my sooner. And I don't
have to die at time to do the two
		

			rockets of dihedral Masjid as
well, you will get the reward with
		

			this one because you can
incorporate the two. The reason
		

			why this doesn't work in shawanna,
according to many scholars is
		

			because of the calculation here,
right? Because what's going on
		

			here is that every fast of Ramadan
is assumed to give you 10 times
		

			the reward. So that's 300 rewards
for the everyday of Ramadan, if
		

			you've missed 10 days, you've
missed 10 days of reward. So
		

			you've got 100 days missing, right
100 days missing. So now you have
		

			to make those up, do you
understand you have to make those
		

			up, then do the shovel ones will
give you will, which will give you
		

			the additional 60 days. So in
Ramadan, a woman who's had 10 days
		

			of menstruation would have only
done 20 days of fast thus got 200
		

			days of reward,
		

			then she has to make up the 10
days and hopefully get the reward
		

			of that extra 100 days. So that's
300 days, now she's got the full
		

			reward of Ramadan, then the six
days of shorewall. So that's 60.
		

			Because in the otherwise the
calculation won't work here. So in
		

			this particular case, you can't
add the two and combine. But in
		

			any other case, if you but in any
other case, the other thing you
		

			have to keep in mind is that the
forward has to be the primary
		

			intention. The novel is just the
side intends, for example, where
		

			it works very well. If you've got
cover prayers to make up Miss
		

			prayers to make up in Ramadan,
you're going to do Tahajjud prayer
		

			inshallah or in any other time. So
in that tahajjud you Tahajjud
		

			prayer you do Kadar pray instead
intended to be cover and
		

			automatically you will get the
reward of the 100 because you're
		

			doing it at that time. So there it
works. But here because the
		

			calculation won't fit, it doesn't
work here. According to many
		

			scholars, there is a tail off
about this, but that is according
		

			to many scholars. And I think that
sounds like a very plausible
		

			understanding of this issue here.
		

			Does Allah Krishna