Abdur Rahman ibn Yusuf Mangera – Q&A Alcohol Issues
![Abdur Rahman ibn Yusuf Mangera](https://artwork.muslimcentral.com/abdur-rahman-ibn-yusuf-mangera-150x150.jpg)
AI: Summary ©
AI: Transcript ©
In products which have alcohol like perfume, etc, if it's made
from something apart from grapes and dates is this permissible to
use, like one item inquiry was made of sugar cane with a
chemical? Yes, those things are generally allowed to use.
It's better to avoid, but in some things where you can hide hardly
avoid a small alcohol content, then if it's a minor alcohol
content, and it's not made from grapes or dates, and it's in a
very stable product, then aroma have allowed it
for particular purposes. Like there's a, there's a need for
gaining strength to, you know, for prayer for medicinal purposes, or
whatever the case is. The problem is that we have an issue is that
our there's a small, a small, minut amount of alcohol that's
used in many, many flavorings and so on. So the question that arises
there is,
is that it's in everything is it's very difficult to avoid. So if
it's in a minut amount, then some scholars have allowed that as long
as it's not from grapes or dates, because if it's from grapes,
dates, or, you know, dried dates, or
sultanas, raisins or whatever, then that will not be allowed at
all, even in a small amount. Right. This one, there's leniency
in that generally, it's industrial alcohol of some sort. And this one
is made of sugar cane.
And that's only allowed, because it's part of something like that.
And it's not been drunk as wine, or as beer. So somebody says,
okay, beer is not made of grapes, it has made a barley or something.
So I should be able to have rice beer or something. No, because
you're drinking like beer. In fact, what the LMR say is that if
you drink a drink in in a way that you drink wine, then that's even
wrong, because you're showing resemblance. So if you have a
schouler, right, grape juice, and you've got it in a flute, or in
one of those wine glasses, and you're doing the you know,
whatever it is, what do they do the when they click the glasses
together, and you're pretending it's wine, that's haram, they say.
That's why I have a massive issue with alcohol free beer. Because
it's just like beer at the end of the day. That's why many of them
have said even that is haram, even though it doesn't have sufficient
alcohol in there, because it's drunk like alcohol for the sake of
alcohol. Now, if somebody's got a problem with alcohol, and the only
way they're going to wean themselves off like nicotine
patches, and they're drinking maybe alcohol free beer, privately
that's up to them that's different, but to introduce it,
right as
just to look cool or to resemble or whatever that the old might
have not allowed, even though it's alcohol free.